Mince pies are one of the great traditions of Christmas – so much so that, for some people, eating the first mince pie of the year signifies the start of the festive season. While mince pie fans might believe there’s no improving a classic, retailers annually compete to create new takes on the traditional festive treat, making mince pies in all sorts of flavours, from frangipane to tiramisu and salted caramel – and not all of them are successes.

The delicious. team put 12 flavoured mince pies from 10 major retailers to the test – including gin, amaretto, Irish cream and black forest flavours – to determine if any of these additions really do improve a classic mince pie. Testing was conducted blind and without packaging, so tasters didn’t know who produced each product or how much it cost. Keep scrolling to discover our pick of the most intriguing flavoured mince pies for 2023. What do you reckon Father Christmas would think of a bakewell mince pie?