A good fish pie is generous and gentle: large, tender flakes of fish and plump prawns held in a creamy sauce, with a thick lid of mash crisped and golden at the peaks. A poor one is watery, with dry, broken fish and a topping that sinks into the filling.

The difference comes down to a few decisions that are easy to get right once you know why they matter. How long to poach the fish, how to turn the poaching milk into the sauce, how thick that sauce needs to be and when the topping goes on. This guide walks through each stage, then gives a recipe to bring them together.

Choosing the fish

A classic fish pie uses a mix. Smoked fish brings depth and a savoury, slightly salty note; white fish gives large, clean flakes; prawns add sweetness and a contrast in texture.

Smoked haddock is the traditional choice. Look for undyed fillets, which are pale cream rather than bright yellow. For the white fish, use thick fillets of cod, haddock, hake or pollock, which hold together in large pieces. Thin fillets such as plaice will break up. Ask your fishmonger to skin the fillets and check for pin bones by running your fingertips along the flesh.

Raw peeled king prawns cook through in the oven and stay juicy. Cooked prawns turn rubbery if baked for long, so if that is all you can get, scatter them in at the very end of assembly.

Why poach in milk

Poaching the fish briefly in milk does two jobs. It starts the cooking, and it turns the milk into a light fish stock that becomes the base of the sauce, so none of the flavour is lost.

The key word is briefly. The fish will spend another half an hour in the oven, so it needs only 3-4 minutes in barely simmering milk, just until the outside turns opaque. Any longer and it will be dry and stringy by the time the pie is served.

Getting the sauce right

The sauce is a béchamel made with the poaching milk. It needs to be thicker than you might expect, roughly the consistency of thick custard, because the fish releases liquid as it bakes. A sauce that looks right in the pan will be thin and watery on the plate.

Let the sauce cool before you add the fish. Hot sauce keeps cooking the fish and breaks it up as you stir. It also makes the mash sink when it goes on top. A cooled, thick filling gives the topping a firm base to sit on.

Fish pie recipe

Serves 6. Hands-on time 1 hour, plus cooling. Oven time 30-35 min.

Ingredients

For the topping:

1.4kg floury potatoes, such as Maris Piper or King Edward, peeled and cut into even chunks

60g unsalted butter

100ml whole milk

1 large egg yolk

40g mature Cheddar, finely grated

For the filling:

750ml whole milk

1 bay leaf

½ onion

400g skinless undyed smoked haddock fillet

450g skinless thick white fish fillet, such as cod, hake or pollock

70g unsalted butter

1 large leek, finely sliced

70g plain flour

100ml double cream

1 tsp Dijon mustard

1 lemon, zested

small bunch flat-leaf parsley, finely chopped

small bunch dill, finely chopped

250g raw peeled king prawns

You’ll also need:

a 2 litre ovenproof dish, about 30cm x 20cm

Method

Boil the potatoes in salted water for 15-20 minutes until a knife slides through easily. Drain well and leave in the colander for 3 minutes to steam dry, then mash with the butter and milk until smooth. Beat in the egg yolk and season. The yolk helps the mash brown and hold its shape.

Meanwhile, put the milk, bay leaf and onion in a wide pan and bring to a gentle simmer. Add the fish in a single layer and poach for 3-4 minutes until just opaque on the outside. Lift the fish onto a plate with a slotted spoon. Strain the milk into a jug.

Melt the butter in a saucepan over a medium-low heat, add the leek and cook for 8 minutes until soft but not coloured. Stir in the flour and cook for 2 minutes. Gradually whisk in the warm poaching milk and simmer, stirring, for 5 minutes until very thick and smooth.

Take the sauce off the heat and stir in the cream, mustard, lemon zest, parsley and dill. Taste and season carefully, as the smoked haddock is already salty. Leave to cool for 20 minutes.

Heat the oven to 200°C/180°C fan/gas 6. Break the fish into large chunks, about 4cm, discarding any bones, and spread over the base of the dish with the prawns. Pour over the cooled sauce and fold very gently so everything is coated without breaking the fish.

Spoon the mash over in small dollops, starting at the edges to seal in the filling, then spread it gently to join up. Rough up the surface with a fork so the ridges catch and crisp. Scatter over the Cheddar.

Set the dish on a baking tray to catch any drips and bake for 30-35 minutes until the topping is golden, the filling is bubbling at the edges and the prawns are pink and cooked through. Rest for 10 minutes before serving with buttered peas or greens.

Variations

Add 3 hard-boiled eggs, quartered, to the filling for a traditional touch.

Swap a third of the white fish for skinless salmon fillet for colour and richness.

Replace the mash with a mix of potato and celeriac, or top the pie with sliced cooked potatoes brushed with butter.

Add a handful of spinach, wilted and squeezed dry, to the sauce.

Troubleshooting

Watery filling: the sauce was too thin, or wet fish went in without draining. Make the sauce thicker than seems right, and let the poached fish sit on its plate for a few minutes to release liquid before adding it.

Dry, stringy fish: it was poached too long. Take it out as soon as the outside turns opaque.

Mash sinking into the filling: the sauce was hot or thin when the topping went on. Cool the filling and start the mash at the edges.

Pale topping: the mash was too wet or the oven was not hot enough. Steam-dry the potatoes well, include the egg yolk and finish under a hot grill for 2-3 minutes if needed.

Making ahead and freezing

Assemble the pie, cool it completely, cover and chill for up to 24 hours. Bake straight from the fridge for 45-50 minutes until golden and piping hot in the centre.

To freeze, use only fish and prawns that have not been frozen before: the Food Standards Agency advises eating defrosted food within 24 hours and not refreezing it. Wrap the assembled, unbaked pie well and freeze. Defrost overnight in the fridge, then bake as above until steaming hot all the way through.